i. Fundamental value
ii. Quality investments with a margin of safety
iii. Only invest in what we understand
iv. Diversification and concentration are balanced
v. Communication
Intrinsic (or fundamental) value is the cash generated by an enterprise or asset over its useful life. Intrinsic value is earned in the future as dividends, interest, and principal are paid or as retained earnings are successfully reinvested.
Risk is the likelihood and potential magnitude of a permanent decline in the earning power or asset value of an enterprise, or the payment of a market price at purchase which is higher than intrinsic value. Our goal is to mitigate risk through integrity with our investment principles and investment process quality.
When buying, we never confuse intrinsic value with market price. Market price is what we pay. Intrinsic value is what we get. Market price may be found quoted daily from news services or ascertained from past transaction records. Intrinsic value is determined by enterprise cash flows.
Market price, it follows, is not a barometer we would use to evaluate corporate performance. Our evaluation of corporate performance is based on items such as income, assets, and return on capital. We view the price of a security simply as a record of what others – well informed or not – were willing to pay for it at various times in the past.
Intrinsic value is such a critical concept because it is the only reference point for what an investment is actually worth, and therefore, whether or not the market price is fair, high, or low. Two facts support this view. First, the theoretical point that an investment is worth the present value of its future cash flows is self-evident and undisputed. Second, new era theories that have driven market prices to speculative levels in the short run have always succumbed to intrinsic value in the long run.
The quality of a security is defined by the reliability of the cash flows or assets which comprise its intrinsic value. The quality of an investment is defined by the price paid for the intrinsic value received.
A quantifiable margin of safety is one of the hallmarks of a quality investment. For equity investments, the intrinsic value of a company must be significantly greater than its price.
True understanding is built upon high probability statements about security values. It requires a dogged determination to get to the bottom of things and an equally dogged honesty about whether or not we did.
Understanding is also relative. We aim to achieve better than average returns which requires understanding security values better than average. The problem is most investment managers believe they are better than average.
Competence and honesty are the keys to assuring that we are not fooling ourselves. Competence means that we are capable of estimating security values and returns for both our portfolios and the markets in which we participate. Honesty means that we are candid about our relative return advantage or lack thereof, and only commit capital when we believe we have an advantage.
Proper diversification is paramount to quality at the portfolio level. Proper diversification is achieved when the overall portfolio return is protected from unexpected adverse results in individual holdings, industries, countries, or other risk factors.
Proper concentration can be risk reducing as well as value enhancing. Concentration refers to making greater commitments to more attractive investments. The greater the difference between intrinsic value and market price, the more robust our knowledge of an investment’s value, and the lower the risk of the investment, the more capital we are willing to concentrate in that investment.
Successfully executed, concentration has three benefits: (a) returns are enhanced by selecting investments with the highest probability of success, (b) risk is reduced by avoiding mediocre and poor commitments, and (c) knowledge is improved by concentrating the analytical effort.
A concentrated portfolio with fewer holdings is desirable when value-to-price, understanding, and quality are high. A low-cost, more widely diversified approach to a market is appropriate when there are no clear advantages in understanding, and therefore, in our ability to evaluate quality or estimate value-to-price.
One of the greatest risks investors face is selling low in a panic. We believe education and communication can greatly reduce this risk. We explain to investors the difference between intrinsic and market value and openly share the rationale behind our investment decision-making. We believe this may significantly reduce the risk of investors selling at market bottoms or buying at market tops.
Communication is also important for evaluating an investment manager’s abilities. Luck, risk, and a bull market can make an incompetent manager look brilliant. Conversely, every manager will under-perform at some time, and this may be the best time to invest with them. Investors must look beyond performance to evaluate manager competence. To aid current and prospective investors in this endeavor, we regularly discuss the strategy and holdings behind our performance, and candidly address both our successes and mistakes.
ACR Alpine Capital Research is a fundamental valuation based asset management firm. Our investment philosophy is rooted in principles essential for successfully evaluating fundamental value and risk, which we believe is the key to investment success.